My son (22) read this book and enjoyed it. He isn’t a man of many words until he gets to talking about something he is passionate about. At first it was difficult to get much out of him but over time he would bring up scenes and dialogue from the book. He thought some of the scenes were a bit over the top but not enough to knock stars from the rating. He says it’s well worth four stars and he really enjoyed reading about the primary characters and their adventures. He wasn’t so sure about the whole forgetting issue but it wasn’t a major issue. We received an ARC through Masquerade Mob in exchange for an honest review.